A while back, I posted an article about creating a WhiteList for access to SQL Server. Since then I have received a bit of feedback that it was not working as designed. My apologies for taking so long, but I believe I have come up with a fix.
The main issue is the trigger will block some or even all access to the server after it’s created. As it turns out, the issues were really permission being denied. To see it in action, let’s create everything using the original code from here.
We’ll add 1 row to the WhiteList table should allow all users from the workstation, ECHOBASE1, access, regardless of its IP address.
Next, we’ll create a SQL login with only connect permission to the server and nothing else.
CREATE LOGIN LogonTriggerTest WITH PASSWORD = 'Password1';
Finally, we’ll open a new query window using that login.
As you can see, we are denied access to the server because of the logon trigger. If we look in the Errorlog, we can see that we lack the VIEW SERVER STATE permission.
This was my first mistake. I did my initial testing using an administrative login. Most users are not admins; therefore, they will not have the permission required to view sys.dm_exec_connections. I was using this DMV to get the IP address of the client connection, and it requires the VIEW SERVER STATE permission. To get around this, I can use the CONNECTIONPROPERTY function, as it does not require any additional permissions.
Now let’s try to connect again.
Again, we failed. This would be my second mistake. I failed to grant SELECT access to the WhiteList table. By default, a user is will have public permission to the master database, but no permission to the table. To solve this, we can grant permission to the public database role. This will allow any authenticated user to read from the WhiteList table.
GRANT SELECT ON dbo.WhiteList TO public;
Finally, our connection to SQL Server is successful. Using the same code from the trigger, we can compare it what’s in the WhiteList table.
ORIGINAL_LOGIN() AS 'LoginName'
,HOST_NAME() AS 'HostName'
,CONNECTIONPROPERTY('client_net_address') AS 'HostIpAddress';
SELECT * FROM dbo.WhiteList;
If I had followed my own rules, I could have discovered most of these issues before posting the original article.
The fully updated code is below. Please let me know if you run into any other issues with this new version. I also added another column to the WhiteList table that can be used for hold comments. The idea is to provide some documentation about what the white-listed item is attempting to do.
IF OBJECT_ID('dbo.WhiteList') IS NOT NULL
DROP TABLE dbo.WhiteList;
CREATE TABLE dbo.WhiteList(
Id INT IDENTITY(1,1) PRIMARY KEY
GRANT SELECT ON dbo.WhiteList TO PUBLIC;
VALUES ('*','ECHOBASE1','*','Any user from the workstation "ECHOBASE1" is allowed to connect, regardless of IP address.')
,('WebSiteLogin','webserver1','192.168.100.55','Only the WebSiteLogin from webserver1 with an IP of 192.168.100.55 is allowed access.');
CREATE TRIGGER WhiteListTrigger
ON ALL SERVER FOR LOGON
@LoginName VARCHAR(255) = ORIGINAL_LOGIN()
,@HostName VARCHAR(255) = HOST_NAME()
,@HostIpAddress VARCHAR(50) = CONVERT(VARCHAR(50),CONNECTIONPROPERTY('client_net_address'));
SELECT COUNT(*) FROM dbo.WhiteList
WHERE ((LoginName = @LoginName) OR (LoginName = '*'))
AND((HostName = @HostName) OR (HostName = '*'))
AND((HostIpAddress = @HostIpAddress) OR (HostIpAddress = '*'))
) = 0